| Game Date | Arena | Score | Opponent | Location | Outcome | Game Chart |
| Sat 11/10/2012 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 74 - 59 | 221 (18-12) Elon at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.993 |
| Tue 11/13/2012 | Cintas Center, Cincinnati, OH
| 62 - 47 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 61 (17-14) Xavier | Away | L | 0.193 |
| Mon 11/19/2012 |
| 71 - 72 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 12 (26-9) Marquette | Neutral | W | 0.333 |
| Tue 11/20/2012 | Lahaina Civic Center, Maui, HI
| 71 - 82 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 21 (24-11) North Carolina | Neutral | W | 0.903 |
| Wed 11/21/2012 | Lahaina Civic Center, Maui, HI
| 78 - 61 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 42 (22-13) Illinois | Neutral | L | 0.097 |
| Sat 12/01/2012 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 67 - 53 | 258 (15-15) Ball St at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.982 |
| Wed 12/05/2012 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 87 - 55 | 311 (4-26) IUPUI at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.999 |
| Sat 12/08/2012 | Welsh-Ryan Arena, Evanston, IL
| 65 - 74 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 104 (13-19) Northwestern | Away | W | 0.838 |
| Sat 12/15/2012 | Bankers Life Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 88 - 86 | 5 (29-7) Indiana at 24 (26-9) Butler | Neutral | W | 0.530 |
| Sat 12/22/2012 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 75 - 67 | 92 (20-15) Evansville at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.888 |
| Sat 12/29/2012 | Memorial Gym, Nashville, TN
| 49 - 68 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 71 (16-17) Vanderbilt | Away | W | 0.866 |
| Wed 01/02/2013 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 70 - 57 | 272 (9-22) Pennsylvania at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.980 |
| Sat 01/05/2013 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 57 - 44 | 346 (4-18) New Orleans at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.983 |
| Wed 01/09/2013 | Michael J. Hagan '85 Arena, Philadelphia, PA
| 66 - 72 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 91 (18-14) Saint Josephs | Away | W | 0.622 |
| Sat 01/12/2013 | University of Dayton Arena, Dayton, OH
| 73 - 79 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 72 (17-14) Dayton | Away | W | 0.877 |
| Wed 01/16/2013 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 62 - 47 | 63 (19-15) Richmond at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.972 |
| Sat 01/19/2013 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 64 - 63 | 9 (31-3) Gonzaga at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.639 |
| Wed 01/23/2013 | Tom Gola Arena, Philadelphia, PA
| 54 - 53 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 59 (24-10) La Salle | Away | L | 0.624 |
| Sat 01/26/2013 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 83 - 71 | 36 (24-10) Temple at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.791 |
| Thu 01/31/2013 | Chaifetz Arena, St. Louis, MO
| 75 - 58 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 16 (28-7) Saint Louis | Away | L | 0.078 |
| Sat 02/02/2013 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 75 - 68 | 120 (8-21) Rhode Island at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.913 |
| Wed 02/06/2013 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 77 - 58 | 110 (14-15) St. Bonaventure at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.958 |
| Sat 02/09/2013 | Charles E. Smith Center, Washington, DC
| 56 - 59 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 124 (13-17) G. Washington | Away | W | 0.911 |
| Wed 02/13/2013 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 67 - 71 | 107 (20-12) Charlotte at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | L | 0.423 |
| Sat 02/16/2013 | Rose Hill Gym, New York, NY
| 63 - 68 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 226 (7-24) Fordham | Away | W | 0.871 |
| Tue 02/19/2013 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 68 - 49 | 172 (8-22) Duquesne at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.996 |
| Fri 02/22/2013 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 61 - 65 | 16 (28-7) Saint Louis at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | L | 0.450 |
| Sat 03/02/2013 | Stuart Siegel Center, Richmond, VA
| 84 - 52 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 13 (27-9) VCU | Away | L | 0.026 |
| Thu 03/07/2013 | William D. Mullins Center, Amherst, MA
| 62 - 73 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 68 (21-12) Massachusetts | Away | W | 0.886 |
| Sat 03/09/2013 | Hinkle Fieldhouse, Indianapolis, IN
| 67 - 62 | 61 (17-14) Xavier at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.825 |
| Thu 03/14/2013 | Barclays Center, Brooklyn, NY
| 73 - 67 | 72 (17-14) Dayton at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.881 |
| Fri 03/15/2013 | Barclays Center, Brooklyn, NY
| 58 - 69 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 59 (24-10) La Salle | Away | W | 0.843 |
| Sat 03/16/2013 | Barclays Center, Brooklyn, NY
| 67 - 56 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 16 (28-7) Saint Louis | Away | L | 0.265 |
| Thu 03/21/2013 | Rupp Arena, Lexington, KY
| 68 - 56 | 81 (27-6) Bucknell at 24 (26-9) Butler | Home | W | 0.855 |
| Sat 03/23/2013 | Rupp Arena, Lexington, KY
| 74 - 72 | 24 (26-9) Butler at 12 (26-9) Marquette | Away | L | 0.513 |