| Game Date | Arena | Score | Opponent | Location | Outcome | Game Chart |
| Sun 11/11/2012 | KFC Yum! Center, Louisville, KY
| 79 - 51 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 1 (35-5) Louisville | Away | L | 0.004 |
| Fri 11/16/2012 | Lavietes Pavilion, Boston, MA
| 79 - 45 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 122 (19-10) Harvard | Away | L | 0.006 |
| Wed 11/21/2012 | Draddy Gymnasium, Riverdale, NY
| 67 - 56 | 289 (6-25) Hofstra at 193 (14-18) Manhattan | Home | W | 0.881 |
| Sat 11/24/2012 | University of Dayton Arena, Dayton, OH
| 66 - 58 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 72 (17-14) Dayton | Away | L | 0.122 |
| Thu 11/29/2012 | Rose Hill Gym, New York, NY
| 58 - 65 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 226 (7-24) Fordham | Away | W | 0.466 |
| Sun 12/02/2012 | Verizon Center, Washington, DC
| 67 - 55 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 124 (13-17) G. Washington | Neutral | L | 0.118 |
| Fri 12/07/2012 | McCann Center, Poughkeepsie, NY
| 62 - 58 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 241 (10-21) Marist | Away | L | 0.222 |
| Sun 12/09/2012 | Draddy Gymnasium, Riverdale, NY
| 75 - 55 | 307 (8-24) Siena at 193 (14-18) Manhattan | Home | W | 0.899 |
| Sun 12/16/2012 | Wellness, Recreation and Athletic Center, Brooklyn, NY
| 75 - 48 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 270 (20-14) Long Island | Away | L | 0.137 |
| Sat 12/22/2012 | Barclays Center, Brooklyn, NY
| 63 - 57 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 177 (14-18) South Carolina | Neutral | L | 0.243 |
| Sat 12/29/2012 | Francis S. Levien Gymnasium, New York, NY
| 69 - 58 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 250 (10-16) Columbia | Away | L | 0.063 |
| Tue 01/01/2013 | Draddy Gymnasium, Riverdale, NY
| 44 - 50 | 132 (24-8) Stony Brook at 193 (14-18) Manhattan | Home | L | 0.381 |
| Fri 01/04/2013 | Yanitelli Center, Jersey City, NJ
| 53 - 55 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 309 (9-21) St. Peters | Away | W | 0.473 |
| Sun 01/06/2013 | Hynes Athletics Center, New Rochelle, NY
| 78 - 70 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 105 (20-14) Iona | Away | L | 0.145 |
| Thu 01/10/2013 | Draddy Gymnasium, Riverdale, NY
| 60 - 69 | 164 (19-15) Rider at 193 (14-18) Manhattan | Home | L | 0.300 |
| Sun 01/13/2013 | Draddy Gymnasium, Riverdale, NY
| 65 - 53 | 241 (10-21) Marist at 193 (14-18) Manhattan | Home | W | 0.943 |
| Thu 01/17/2013 | Koessler Athletic Center, Buffalo, NY
| 64 - 60 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 117 (20-14) Canisius | Away | L | 0.106 |
| Sat 01/19/2013 | Gallagher Center, Niagara, NY
| 64 - 60 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 146 (19-14) Niagara | Away | L | 0.222 |
| Fri 01/25/2013 | Draddy Gymnasium, Riverdale, NY
| 41 - 51 | 145 (23-12) Loyola (MD) at 193 (14-18) Manhattan | Home | L | 0.138 |
| Sun 01/27/2013 | Alumni Gymnasium, Lawrenceville, NJ
| 51 - 62 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 164 (19-15) Rider | Away | W | 0.806 |
| Fri 02/01/2013 | Times Union Center, Albany, NY
| 66 - 63 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 307 (8-24) Siena | Away | L | 0.188 |
| Sun 02/03/2013 | Draddy Gymnasium, Riverdale, NY
| 57 - 49 | 309 (9-21) St. Peters at 193 (14-18) Manhattan | Home | W | 0.603 |
| Thu 02/07/2013 | Draddy Gymnasium, Riverdale, NY
| 67 - 54 | 117 (20-14) Canisius at 193 (14-18) Manhattan | Home | W | 0.874 |
| Tue 02/12/2013 | Alumni Hall, Fairfield, CT
| 40 - 62 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 235 (19-16) Fairfield | Neutral | W | 0.900 |
| Fri 02/15/2013 | Draddy Gymnasium, Riverdale, NY
| 74 - 73 | 105 (20-14) Iona at 193 (14-18) Manhattan | Home | W | 0.384 |
| Sun 02/17/2013 | Draddy Gymnasium, Riverdale, NY
| 56 - 60 | 146 (19-14) Niagara at 193 (14-18) Manhattan | Home | L | 0.258 |
| Sat 02/23/2013 | Alumni Arena, Buffalo, NY
| 64 - 65 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 185 (12-20) Buffalo | Away | W | 0.576 |
| Fri 03/01/2013 | Draddy Gymnasium, Riverdale, NY
| 34 - 31 | 235 (19-16) Fairfield at 193 (14-18) Manhattan | Home | W | 0.604 |
| Sun 03/03/2013 | Reitz Arena, Baltimore, MD
| 63 - 61 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 145 (23-12) Loyola (MD) | Away | L | 0.091 |
| Sat 03/09/2013 | MassMutual Center, Springfield, MA
| 52 - 55 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 145 (23-12) Loyola (MD) | Neutral | W | 0.485 |
| Sun 03/10/2013 | MassMutual Center, Springfield, MA
| 60 - 42 | 235 (19-16) Fairfield at 193 (14-18) Manhattan | Home | W | 0.733 |
| Mon 03/11/2013 | MassMutual Center, Springfield, MA
| 60 - 57 | 193 (14-18) Manhattan at 105 (20-14) Iona | Away | L | 0.121 |